Readnihongo app icon

ReadNihongo

Stories you can finish

N3

Substitution and Trade-Off: 〜かわりに

About 10 minutes · written and reviewed by Haruki Yamamoto

Section 1 of 3

Core meaning

〜かわりに means “instead of,” “in place of,” or “in exchange for.” The sentence often shows substitution: A is not chosen or not possible, so B is done instead. It can also show a trade-off between good and bad points.

  1. Target signal

    車で行くかわりに、電車で行こう。

    Let's go by train instead of by car.

    One option is substituted with another.

    Vocabulary notes
    こう
    like this; this way
    行くいく
    to go
    電車でんしゃ
    train
  2. Compare in context

    この部屋は狭いかわりに、家賃が安い。

    This room is small, but in exchange the rent is cheap.

    The lower rent is the trade-off for a smaller room.

    Vocabulary notes
    この
    this
    安いやすい
    cheap; inexpensive
    家賃やちん
    rent

Section 2 of 3

Common uses

A practical way to remember 〜かわりに is to ask: what is being given up, replaced, or balanced? In some sentences it is a direct substitution. In others it is more like a trade-off between two qualities.

  1. Target signal

    今日は私が料理するかわりに、弟が皿を洗う。

    I will cook today, and in exchange my younger brother will wash the dishes.

    One person's action is exchanged for another person's action.

    Vocabulary notes
    料理するりょうりする
    to cook
    する
    to do
    今日きょう
    today
  2. Preview

    手書きするかわりに、パソコンで入力した。

    I typed it on a computer instead of writing it by hand.

    The computer is used in place of handwriting.

    Vocabulary notes
    パソコン
    personal computer
    手書きてがき
    handwritten
    した
    did

Section 3 of 3

Reading notes

Writers use 〜かわりに when comparing options, explaining policy, or describing compromise. It is especially useful in reviews and decision-making passages because it shows what was exchanged for what.

  1. Target signal

    便利なかわりに、費用がかなりかかる。

    It is convenient, but it costs quite a lot.

    The second clause presents the cost or drawback that balances the convenience.

    Vocabulary notes
    かかる
    to hang over; to cover
    かなり
    fairly; quite
    かな
    I wonder; maybe
  2. Preview

    平日は出張が多いかわりに、週末は家族と過ごすようにしている。

    Because weekdays involve many business trips, he makes a point of spending weekends with the family.

    The sentence shows a compensating balance across weekdays and weekends.

    Vocabulary notes
    ている〜ている
    to be doing; to be in a resulting state
    ように〜ように
    so that ...; in order to ...
    ように
    so that; in order to

Reading in context

Read for meaning before checking the answer

Before you read

Read once for the situation. Then notice how 〜かわりに changes the meaning before you check the translation.

車で行くかわりに、電車で行こう。 この部屋は狭いかわりに、家賃が安い。 今日は私が料理するかわりに、弟が皿を洗う。 手書きするかわりに、パソコンで入力した。 便利なかわりに、費用がかなりかかる。 平日は出張が多いかわりに、週末は家族と過ごすようにしている。

Show English translation

Let's go by train instead of by car. This room is small, but in exchange the rent is cheap. I will cook today, and in exchange my younger brother will wash the dishes. I typed it on a computer instead of writing it by hand. It is convenient, but it costs quite a lot. Because weekdays involve many business trips, he makes a point of spending weekends with the family.

Contextual questions

Answer from the passage before you reveal each explanation.

  1. What is the first reading job for this passage?

    • Identify the situation and how 〜かわりに changes it.
    • Translate every word before using context.
    • Ignore the ending because only vocabulary matters.
    • Choose an answer before reading the full passage.
    Check the answer

    Identify the situation and how 〜かわりに changes it.

    The goal is to use the situation first, then confirm the role of 〜かわりに in context.

Guided practice

Apply the lesson in a few different ways

Work through each prompt, then check the explanation before moving on.

Activity 1 of 4Choose the best context

What idea is central to 〜かわりに?

Activity 2 of 4Fill the blank

Complete the chunk that carries the lesson meaning (〜かわりに).

車で行くかわりに、電車で行___。

Activity 3 of 4Put it in order

Put these related examples back into the order used in the lesson.

  1. 1この部屋は狭いかわりに、家賃が安い。
  2. 2今日は私が料理するかわりに、弟が皿を洗う。
  3. 3車で行くかわりに、電車で行こう。
Activity 4 of 4Infer from the passage

What should guide your interpretation of 〜かわりに in the mini-reading?

Mastery check 1/3

What idea is central to 〜かわりに?